People sometimes
inquire what form of government is most suitable for an artist to live under.
To this question there is only one answer. The form of government that is most
suitable to the artist is no government at all. Authority over him and his art
is ridiculous. It has been stated that under despotisms artists have produced
lovely work. This is not quite so. Artists have visited despots, not as
subjects to be tyrannized over, but as wandering wonder-makers, as fascinating
vagrant personalities, to be entertained and charmed and suffered to be at
peace, and allowed to create. There is this to be said in favor of the despot,
that he, being an individual, may have culture, while the mob, being a monster,
has none. One who is an Emperor and King may stoop down to pick up a brush for
a painter, but when the democracy stoops down it is merely to throw mud. And
yet the democracy have not so far to stoop as the emperor. In fact, when they
want to throw mud they have not to stoop at all. But there is no necessity to
separate the monarch from the mob; all authority is equally bad….
There are three kinds of despots. There is the despot who
tyrannizes over the body. There is the despot who tyrannizes over the soul.
There is the despot who tyrannizes over the soul and body alike. The first is
called the Prince. The second is called the Pope. The third is called the
People. The Prince may be cultivated. Many Princes have been. Yet in the Prince
there is danger.... It is better for the artist not to live with Princes. The
Pope may be cultivated. Many Popes have been; the bad Popes have been. The bad
Popes loved Beauty, almost as passionately, nay, with as much passion as the
good Popes hated Thought. To the wickedness of the Papacy humanity owes much.
The goodness of the Papacy owes a terrible debt to humanity. Yet, though the Vatican has
kept the rhetoric of its thunders, and lost the rod of its lightning, it is
better for the artist not to live with Popes….
And as for the People, what of them and their authority?
Perhaps of them and their authority one has spoken enough. Their authority is a
thing blind, deaf, hideous, grotesque, tragic, amusing, serious, and obscene.
It is impossible for the artist to live with the People. All despots bribe. The
people bribe and brutalize. Who told them to exercise authority? They were made
to live, to listen, and to love. Someone has done them a great wrong. They have
marred themselves by imitation of their inferiors. They have taken the scepter
of the Prince. How should they use it? They have taken the triple tiara of the
Pope. How should they carry its burden? They are as a clown whose heart is
broken. They are as a priest whose soul is not yet born. Let all who love
Beauty pity them. Though they themselves love not Beauty, yet let them pity
themselves. Who taught them the trick of tyranny?
No comments:
Post a Comment
Join the conversation! What is your reaction to the post?